Quilting Evolution Ladder

_MG_6412

Something that I really enjoy is the sociology of the world. I love finding trends and seeing things that maybe others don’t (or do).  Something that is fascinating to me is the constant cycles I see in the quilting community, at least in our “young” “modern” quilting community. I’ve been blogging 4 years now, which is not that much longer than a lot of quilting bloggers out there, but it’s been enough time to really see some of these cycles.  One of the cycles I’ve noticed is in the making of quilts.

_MG_6430

When a person first begins quilting there is the mindset of “just get it done”.  It doesn’t matter how you get there, or how it looks, just get that quilt made.  The new quilter doesn’t care about which way the seams are pressed, or if seams match up, or blocks are square…if points are chopped off. You run out and buy all the nifty quilting tools, which promptly go into a bottom drawer and gather dust.  It’s about learning the very basics of operating your machine and finishing a project at this stage. I think it’s pretty safe to say we all start off this way.  Deny it if you want, but I’m guessing to some degree you were there at the start, and quite honestly, I think this is a great way to start.  Who cares how it looks or how you get to the end product, the important part is to begin.

_MG_6492

Next the quilter starts to notice their seams don’t line up.  They begin to see other’s work and think “why can’t my quilt look like that”. So they see that others are pressing seams, instead of ironing them, using a few pins when sewing (what a pain, but if it will help…), and checking for accurate 1/4” seam allowances.  They are trying to figure out how not to get those points chopped off, and even succeeding on a few.  Which is good enough to them! The quilter is probably still resisting squaring blocks.  The seam ripper is in hand quite often.  Possibly the first one is worn out and a second has been purchased.

_MG_6489
The evolution continues, and now the quilter has reached a plateau.  Things are looking better, but they really would like everything to match and look as refined as some of these winning quilts.  Wonky was fun, but now we want to have more precision, because sometimes “wonky” just looks like you sewed your seam crooked (at least if you’re me). Now the quilter (drat it all) squares those 125 half square triangles for the quilt top. Every last one of them. Pins are now a must.  At every seam.  On each side of the seam.  Blocks are pressed precisely, first from the back and then from the front.  And probably pressed again just before sewing them into rows for the quilt top. Points are never chopped off, and if they are, the seam ripper makes an appearance.  The seam ripper is used less, but is a must in their arsenal, always on hand and never ashamed to be used.

_MG_5923

Finally, or maybe not “finally”, but more of a “somewhat finally”, the quilter is pretty precise in their quilting.  The tools gathering dust in the bottom drawer now come out periodically, and some new ones join the group, because there is the right tool for every job.  They have learned that as wonderful as “modern” quilting is, there is also some value in “traditional”.  Things to be learned and applied to their “modern” aesthetics and techniques.  They realize the new and modern are deeply steeped in the traditional and have a new appreciation for traditional work.  The quilter can now look past the brown calico’s and see the beauty in the pattern, looking past the fabrics that don’t appeal, and apply it to their own modern interests.  If seams don’t match, they rip them out and sew it again, because if they’ve put this much time and effort into it, what is a few more minutes fixing a seam.  Their motto becomes: If you’re going take the time to do something, do it right. 

After this point the true hunt for knowledge begins.  Quilting has become precise and honed and tops are churned out with perfect points and matching seams.  Where does the quilter go from here?  Teaching, pattern writing, more learning on other topics (applique, hand piecing, hand quilting), ...

So what is the point of this post?  No point really.  Just my observations.  I find this all fascinating.  I love seeing these trends and evolutions in quilters and bloggers.  I actually was reading Krista’s post, Old Ladies Know Stuff, and having a little chuckle over the title when I thought, you know, it’s time to write this post.  Everything she has to say is very true, and new to quilting or not, I think it’s worth the read.  I firmly believe in learning from our past and older generations.  I began quilting when there was only one way, what we now consider the traditional way, so my learning has always firmly been in that arena, but I still feel I went through these same steps on the quilting-evolution ladder.  I see a lot of quilters approaching this last stage of quilting right now.  They are coming to understand there is a place for traditional in their modern quilting, and find that they want better results and to take their time.  It’s a good place to be.  You might even consider yourself a quilter by now, because we all know how long it takes for us to except that titles as ours.

_MG_6602

Where do I sit on this “ladder”? I think I’m in that “true hunt for knowledge” stage.  I know how to do just about everything there is in quilting, but I don’t know all the ways to achieve the same result.  I know a little bit about a lot of things, but now I want to learn more and hone some of those other skills.  I want to get better, find better ways, and learn more about the processes behind everything.  I want to learn from others and see what works for them and find what works best for me.  It’s all about the “precise” result for me, and the processes behind them, so learning everything there is to learn and assembling the steps that work best for me is where I comfortably sit.  Where do you feel you sit on this ladder?

23 comments:

  1. Great blog. Pretty accurate observation, I'd have to say, since you nailed me in there. :) I really enjoyed it. Thanks.

    ReplyDelete
  2. That's exactly where I started and how I progressed. I'm now refining what I know and still learning new ways to do things BETTER.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Beautiful pictures amongst a beautiful post... I have been quilting for 18 years and I'm still learning things and perfecting my methods...does one ever stop?

    ReplyDelete
  4. The most wonderful thing about quilting is the learning. It just never stops.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I began quilting way back when there was only one way to do things too! Seams pressed to the side! I still have to fight the urge to think it's "wrong" to press them open! I still haven't pressed any seams open, but it's getting easier to see lots of other people doing it :-)

    ReplyDelete
  6. Exactly! With each quilt I strive to have better seams and learn a new technique. I was just wondering if anyone ever gets to the point where they make a PERFECT quilt?!

    ReplyDelete
  7. yes!! I never thought it through but this is RIGHT ON THE MONEY! EXACTLY! Loved reading this!!

    ReplyDelete
  8. I'm a new, new, new quilter. I improved a whole heck of a lot even between my first and second tops. Straighter seams, a pretty uniformly accurate 1/4 inch seam the whole way through, etc. I guess I'm at the bottom of the ladder. I'm still learning, but getting better with every stitch I sew. It also helps that I'm about as far from a perfectionist as one can get, so my mistakes don't really bother me. I just try not to make the same ones from one project to the next, and that makes me happy enough. I've also become much more likely to rip out a seam and re-do it if something is messed up, which I think is good for me.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Hmm, I don't think I fit any rung. Can I be on all of them?

    I will continue to press my seams open more often than not (as I prefer the flatter feel/look to the quilt top), but I do square blocks about half the time, but I hate redoing anything (in any part of my life), but I've always leaned more towards traditional (love modern fabric, love traditional patterns), but I have always been interested in learning about (and trying occasionally) different techniques and different ways to do the different techniques, but ...

    Yeah, I'm all over the place. But I've never been very typical.

    I have evolved into caring about accurate 1/4" seams. That's one thing I can remember changing over the 3 years I've been sewing (with a grand total of 4 quilts; told ya I'm slow!).

    ReplyDelete
  10. I began quilting as a kid using needle, thread and fabric and all by hand. My applique work was obvious with large stitches in white or black thread and my blocks were, well, rather rudimentary and crude with a (much) greater than 1/4 inch seam allowance! Still, after almost thirty years of quilting, I haven't gotten the bug to make sure my seams are all perfect, my points are sharp, and my blocks are all squared and lined up. Maybe one day.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Hmmm...I think I'm at the plateau, although admittedly my points and seams don't always match up perfectly (but I tell myself that linen is tricky, ahem)! But I've never been happy to just whack a quilt together even my first one, I think either you are a perfectionist or you're not, and I'm not! Perfectionists might not be able to produce a perfect quilt but it worries them when they don't. Non-perfectionists are the ones who don't worry - but they don't progress either. Perfectionists notice the defects and strive to get better each time. So I'm striving but I doubt I'll get to the quest for knowlege stage because I don't have the time to really work at it - what do they say 10,000 hours at something to become accomplished? No I tell a lie, I can work on getting to the next level of technical proficiency, starting with my 1/4" seams and my pressing. I do love a properly pressed block!

    ReplyDelete
  12. I mean, I AM a perfectionist. So much so that I have to come back and correct my comment because I can't let it alone :D

    ReplyDelete
  13. This post came at the most OPPORTUNE time.
    I started quilting 15 years ago, and dabbled here and there.
    Just this Monday, I was contemplating the thought that I need to accept that I am now a quilter. I care about the finished product. The perfection. I have more WIPS and UFOs than I care to like..it rubs me because I like to think of myself as a crafter, but more and more posts are about my quilts on my blog. *sigh*

    ReplyDelete
  14. I started as a 'schooled' quilter, too. I learned at a 6 week beginner's workshop at my LQS. I am so glad I had that foundation and that first quilt (which, 11 years later sits at the bottom of a cedar chest 2/3 hand quilted!) sparked a passion that I believe I'll have for the rest of my life. I continue to take classes and teach them myself now. I find it ironic, though, that at this stage I am trying to loosen up a bit and not be so AR about everything. I'm trying to free cut and practice unplanned piecing more (however, I still totally get off on complicated trad blocks and still rejoice when they are pressed and actually come out to 12 1/2".) thanks to, you guessed it, a workshop. My most recent was 2 days with 3 of the quilters from Gee's Bend. What a treat to learn improvisation and FUN from these women. Talk about quilting without any rules!

    I think I climb up and down the ladder with alarming frequency. You'd think I'd be in better shape.

    Thanks for linking to my post. I love my clever old lady friends and can't wait to be one for a young quilter one day, too.

    ReplyDelete
  15. I think this is a pretty accurate evolutionary scale! I do kinda agree with ErinMarie about being on more than one rung, especially when it comes to different techniques and skills, On some projects, I'm seasoned, experienced, patient. Others - it's pedal to the metal... :-) I'm all for learning new things though. Probably always will be. Quilting is one of those things that tends to go in a spiral. You circle around to the same ideas but from a much different perspective, building skyward. It's grand!

    ReplyDelete
  16. I love this post!! Thank you for sharing your thoughts on this :-)

    ReplyDelete
  17. Heh. How long does it usually take to grow out of the "just get it done" stage? 'Cause I've been at it for 3 years, and am starting to wonder if I'm a lifer.

    Although some of the other commenters make a good point about being on multiple "rungs;" I will step up or down the effort depending on my intended audience, since kids don't care overmuch about points lining up, but if I'm going to be cuddling under it myself, *I* occasionally do. The more experience I have, the less time consuming/intimidating the little things become, but it is always a balance between "perfectionism gets me a great quilt" and "perfectionism keeps me from trying something else."

    ReplyDelete
  18. My thoughts exactly. :)

    Love your cat...looks just like my Finnian...who also likes to nap on my fabric.

    ReplyDelete
  19. Loving your Blog. Just blogged about my crafty weekend with my girls. I love all the crafty things. So relaxing and great fun :)

    ReplyDelete
  20. I just found your blog after seeing a pin of your double wedding ring mini quilt. I think I am hooked. I completely agree with this post! I started sewing a few years ago, but advanced through these stages pretty quickly. I've made about a dozen quilts and have now begun to obsess over the perfection of seams. I'm "self-taught" or really, internet taught so all my learning has taken place online and through trial and error in my work. I'm currently doing the Farmer's Wife quilt along simply because I felt all 111 blocks could give me a traditional education. And so far, they are - each block takes an hour or more and they are only 6" square. I appreciate your words in this post and will be coming back for more. x April www.bellaloucreative.blogspot.com

    ReplyDelete
  21. I too am facinated by these sorts of things! Although in this case, I feel the opposite happened to me. I started out using all the tools, washing and pressing, etc. But now I like the antique look of a handmade quilt, puckered and uneven.

    ReplyDelete
  22. I too am facinated by these sorts of things! Although in this case, I feel the opposite happened to me. I started out using all the tools, washing and pressing, etc. But now I like the antique look of a handmade quilt, puckered and uneven.

    ReplyDelete

I love hearing from everyone! If you have a question for me, please make sure your email is public with Blogger, otherwise send me an email so that I can get back to you directly.